August 13, 2026
arcanin
you hate that lgbtq people are existing for the whole sake that they exist
devilmine
No
swtcyn
I'm aware Devilmine, but it's not how I meant it. It just came out wrong.
devilmine
U asked if that opinion was reasonable???
gormuck
Yeah honestly it looks like you don't really think anything you are saying ngl
devilmine
like holy
U literally went to Him and said "if ppl ask me to respect other opinions i wont"
๐ญ
be so for fucking real for a second
stop damage controlling
swtcyn
I fully understand, but I don't hate anyone. It's clear as day there I know, but this isn't what I wanted to convey in the slightest bit. It's hard for me to explain further at this rate because none of it will be believable.
devilmine
U LITERALLY SAID "THE MOMENT SOMEONE SHOVES SOMETHING DOWN MY THROAT I LOSE ALL RESPECT FOR YOU"
arcanin
i absolutely cannot ignore what has transpired these last few days
devilmine
But this is just another level
Id recommend you to read what ausk said in their document
arcanin
and just turn a blind eye on
i do not feel comforable staying in a team where we'll gladly allow people like this to stay (edited)
devilmine
Ausk posted something and is a lot more reasonable in my eyes than whatever this is
arcanin
i am growing extremely unconfortable at how these situations are treated by the maintenance team: 2 people exposed back to back for transphobia and overall hate against the LGBTQ community, and nothing has been done after being made aware. i have a severe lack of trust that anything will be done and am on the verge of resigning if this is where things are headed
swtcyn
Precisely which is why I attempted to learn, but instead I had immediately stated something harmful without giving [REDACTED] space to breath.
dreameatergd
This is just extremely unsettling
kazvixx
Well yea being a lgbtphobic in a team half of which are lgbt is a bit weird
dreameatergd
Like I don't know the % but if I had to guess half of us are openly LGBT+ and the other half at the very least has friends that are
devilmine
Clearly
This message has been redacted to protect someone's identity
kazvixx
Im not saying anyone should think as I do
agsilver.
Final thing i have to say, I am genuinely baffled by maintenance decision that this is not an immediate demote, I am sorry but no this is just not okay to have on the team (edited)
dreameatergd
Well you're not the only person in the team though
kazvixx
I don't think views of someone im not interacting actively with should be a problem for me to stay in a team I enjoy working with.
devilmine
I do not feel comfortable around you anymore especially with how ur trying to just try and escape the situation even further
I'm sorry but you need to be demoted or resign and I hope maintenance rethinks their decision
arcanin
i refuse to believe this is a "wording" issue
This message has been redacted to protect someone's identity
devilmine
๐ญ
this is not a screw up
You literally said u lose ALL RESPECT for anyone asking u to respect it or ""shoving it down your throat""
orots
sry i dont wanna engage more either im just disappointed
devilmine
ngl
Its just showing what you truly are
No honestly I'm glad you did this its not a screw up
swtcyn
I'm fully willing to learn.
arcanin
thats not a screw up?
orots
because quite frankly, just holding those views is incredibly destructive
swtcyn
This was very much just one big screw up.
orots
this just isnt something you can reasonably discuss if you dont accept your views being challenged in this situation
devilmine
This is just not put into proper words man this is just you having said ur view more unfiltered
swtcyn
And I'm trying to work on that now.
swtcyn
Absolutely.
polarbeahr
You have to understand that your intentions, be it as good as they can in your own eyes, can have a different effect on different people.
swtcyn
I get it. It's not that I wanted to hurt anyone though. I just couldn't put it into proper words on how I wished to discuss it with [REDACTED] and I thought I could do as such since he said he'd be willing to listen.
arcanin
sorry but with your wording, there's no way in my mind that you didn't mean those things
polarbeahr
With all due respect, the genie's out of the bottle
swtcyn
Again, all I can say is that's not how I wanted it to come off.
gormuck
I feel the same way
devilmine
And we are blaming it in poor wording?
or rather cut them off
g.ben
im not even gonna lie, I am very concerned you being so fine and chill about both these situations thats been the topic of discussion the last few days...
I do not wish to engage with this convo any longer, i just really felt like i had to say this.
devilmine
U literally said u would lose all respect and wouldn't want to talk to someone challenging ur views
swtcyn
Absolutely, I'm really sorry I broke your trust with this and to anyone here who views it similarly. I'll refrain from speaking about it entirely as clearly, since I'm not educated on it. I should just shut my mouth.
kazvixx
I personally stopped being homophobic once a close friend of mine came out to me as a bisexual, good on you to at least trying to learn more by that conversation, but this needs to be done in the most respectful way possible
devilmine
literally
arcanin
how is you saying โI donโt want things forced down my throatโ and โthe moment you start forcing your beliefs on me, I lose all respect and donโt want to associate with youโ wanting to learn man
This message has been redacted to protect someone's identity
dreameatergd
^
devilmine
This is just not misworded dude
"The LBGT community needs to stop feeding nonsense regarding pronouns" as an example
swtcyn
Definitely very harsh and I didn't mean for it to turn out as such.
devilmine
as others mentioned
Everything else is not a lack of wording
swtcyn
Lack of knowledge mainly.
dreameatergd
"Shoving it down our throats" is not wrong wording
orots
this just purely stems from the lack of acceptance to me
agsilver.
SwtCyn, i dont have more to say to you really, but i truly hope you can learn that your views genuinely hurt people and your thoughts of these things are egregious. It will take a while before i truly will feel comfortable around you again.
dreameatergd
Definitely not
kirichux3
its very clear
admittedly I dont think any of the "i worded it wrong" works here ๐ญ
swtcyn
This is where it gets sticky for sure. Thing is I worded what I wanted to talk about super poorly. I genuinely have zero issues with people who have different interests, beliefs, etc. However I poorly said "severely disliked" rather than "it may not be my thing, but I'd like to learn about it more". It wasn't hard to articulate I just ended up not doing as such and I wish I knew why I just dropped a bomb like that not believing in the majority of it and then just ask whether or not it's reasonable.
devilmine
likewise
kazvixx
I personally don't care much myself about anyone's views, as long as ur presence here doesn't harm the team idm u staying, but it seems like kt sparks another drama and needs to be at least worked on
orots
im very uncomfortable with this sorry
this is not as much about it having to do anything with the game as it is maintaining a healthy environment both on the team and as a community figure
arcanin
I am beyond disappointed that someone I considered a friend turned out to be a bigot in disguise, whoโs world view is purely against people like me who are just trying to live their lives like others
dreameatergd
Because it's the one thing they use to dismiss any type of civilized conversation on this topic
Especially the typical "They're shoving down our throats" argument, I really hate that
polarbeahr
Alright, that's understandable. I'm just intrigued as to why you would not decide to step down if you share these views openly in a team that has a lot of people or friends within the LGBTQ community.
This message has been redacted to protect someone's identity
swtcyn
I fully understand you not wanting to associate with me anymore Devilmine. Absolutely do.
It would've been worse if I had tried to keep quiet about it.
devilmine
I see
swtcyn
It was being spread throughout Mods and it would've ended up being brought up here anyways. I went to maintenance myself about it.
kazvixx
I feel like it was forced just to see reactions and make a decision based on them
Well id say no one would like to bring stuff like this up here
devilmine
Im just ngl I dont feel comfortable at all around you for this, I would say I'd be happy that you came forward with this but from all looks u were forced because of said warning to do so
it makes it so much worse to me too
devilmine
Especially because you literally wanted to silence the entire convo about it here
devilmine
Considering too because this is beyond unfair ๐ญ
agsilver.
If nothing happens im probably resigning
devilmine
This is egregious
Yeah no I agree
agsilver.
nah bro
I am appauled at how we will crack down on someone for making an accident following nsfw accounts (which was never intentional) BUT THIS GETS A "FINAL WARNING"
devilmine
Absolutely unacceptable behavior from a Moderator
And it further makes me even more uncomfortable with how you dealt with Ausk being mentioned as transphobic here and trying to silence the convo as a whole and sheds a completely new light on it
I don't want to have anything to do with someone who has views like those in a community that has a large percentage of minorities from that group in it
swtcyn
I can't blame anyone here who's disgusted, disappointed, etc. I'm not defending myself from this either as I'm equally disappointed if not more that this was me who was speaking.
devilmine
Im gonna be fucking honest this should've be a demotion on the spot
swtcyn
I believe it I'm allowed to say that this was requested if me to bring it up here. And to bring extra clarity, yes I've been formally warned. If this were to happene again or if something else comes up, I'll be removed from the team.
liathecat
im gonna go take a shower and think of what i want to say about this because this is to put it lightly very bad
kirichux3
agree with them both, admittedly im quite shocked at some stuff said here and wouldnt have expected it from you swtcyn
liathecat
^ i read all this about 30-40 minutes ago and i couldnt quite formulate a response
agsilver.
Real talk, im just appauled to even see the way things were put initially. This is super disappointing and im quite uncomfortable after reading that as we had been friends in the past and used to hang out even if for a bit. I also am very confused as to why all of this was brought up here.
swtcyn
End.
This was never a good idea and after reflecting I shouldn't have spoken about it to anybody at all or at least I should've kept it in spaces where I already knew were safe and reliable. (such as the private gc made up of around 20-30 people who are around my age-range that also could care less about GD and it's community as their interested in other stuff) My actions of course will not be repeated and I fully understand a lot of you to no longer want to associate with me as this in itself is really soul crushing, concerning and as much as I'd like to be asked about stuff regarding this topic I'm worried that it would only add more fuel to the fire. ESPECIALLY with what else has been going on in modchat lately. This was never meant to lead to this, but at the end of the day this was the result. I'm sorry to [REDACTED] I'm sorry to everyone here in modchat. I'm very much upset at myself for coming off so strongly and how I handled things overall. I'm well aware this interaction with [REDACTED] will make or break friendships between others and will be worse than frowned upon. And as much as it seems like a lie, I did have better intentions at heart. This just so happened to not showcase that. However, if you do wish to talk with me about it privately. I'll do my very best to create a safe space if you'd like to educate me on it so I'm not misinformed/ can learn from you. Again, I deeply apologize to [REDACTED] and everyone else on the team.
After some time, and after he went to sleep because of time zones the next day after he had given himself some time to reflect on the nightmare that occurred. He rightfully un-added me and didn't want to discuss things further to which I fully respected. I never pursued him to go back on his decision either. Me bringing this up here is by no means to motivate him in re-adding me. Bringing this up here was solely to clear the air because I'm very well aware of what's been spread around about me and I'm fully prepared to accept the consequences from the mod team as a whole. Especially close friends of mine who are from the LGBTQ communities. This was the furthest thing from acceptable and even though I meant to articulate myself differently I simply didn't and there's nothing I can do now to fix that. And this is especially true here with my final apology to [REDACTED] as it only dug myself a bigger hole. I very much disregarded what I had said to [REDACTED] as the conversation continued and was confused on why [REDACTED] was upset as I thought I was having the same healthy conversation I've had with others, but that's simply not what happened. I spoke way differently and talked about other aspects that weren't even apart of my conversations with others nor (as stated before) agreed with over half the stuff I had listed originally. I also acknowledge that I shouldn't have been talking about it at all as being a community figure who speaks with many community members daily it is best to be diligent with what you say especially to the public:
๐ผ๏ธ
image.png
67.25 KB
Local
As you can see here I came off very strong and lazily spoke on the topic without much thought on what my beliefs are, but mainly my thought process was "okay cool, this is a safe space". This was obviously not my brightest moment by any means and I completely acknowledge that what I stated here was very disheartening and malicious even though that wasn't my overall intent in the end. I very much articulated my beliefs incorrectly and again, half the stuff I had mentioned there I simply don't agree with myself. If you're wondering, I went to a couple GD friends of mine to discuss the topic because I was merely interested and wanted to be more of an ally/ learn more about my friends rather than drop my quote on quote "beliefs" immediately that automatically created an unsafe space for [REDACTED] to even begin to question, educate me, etc. [REDACTED] was absolutely in the right to feel uncomfortable and unsafe as from the screenshot I'll soon attach they spoke about how being apart of said communities was frowned upon within his environment and in general he felt very self-conscious in regards to that which I naively didn't even consider. Instead, I should've have started with "What it's like to live in your shoes?" and not make it about me right off the bat. This would've given [REDACTED] the chance to actually voice his thoughts, opinions, and from that alone I more than likely would've been educated on topics I wouldn't have even considered, but unfortunately I missed that mark of trying to learn more about my friends (in this instance [REDACTED] . Again, I could've worded things here better as well, but my main focus after learning about how sensitive of a topic this was for him I was more upset that I hurt my friend and prioritized my friend over the topic itself. I didn't mean for that last bit to come off as if I didn't care he was apart of that community in the end as that's obviously a big part of who he is
๐ผ๏ธ
image.png
96.02 KB
Local
I'm very disappointed that this happened, but I'll do my best to articulate everything better this time as in this situation I had made myself out to be insanely homophobic and overall immature. In this discussion I'd like to formally apologize to not only [REDACTED] but to everyone here as I've very much painted myself in a terrible light even though I had the better intentions at heart. I was very ignorant and the way I went about this with [REDACTED] specifically I clearly wasn't paying attention to my phrasing and that I full acknowledge.
Starting off with the context before when I had originally messaged [REDACTED] I was discussing various topics with a vast group of people from different communities. (none of which played GD) Many were religious, (in more ways than one) others were apart of the LGBTQ community, there were also furries there, people who are heavily interested in anime and we all were having far more healthier discussions than the way I spoke about the LGBTQ community and my beliefs towards it when conversing with [REDACTED] My remarks were far harsher, most of the stuff I had listed whilst explaining my beliefs to [REDACTED] weren't even my beliefs at all, and after further reflection this simply isn't a topic I should've discussed to begin with especially with another community figure. I know that now and this won't be repeated, period. Here's where my conversation starts off with [REDACTED]
๐ผ๏ธ
image.png
582.56 KB
Local
swtcyn
I can in a moment. Also can nobody talk here for a bit until I've listed what I'm about to say here so it doesn't get misaligned. ๐
auskgd
Idk how Twitter works, but I remember someone mentioning having other people repost so the post would gain more visibility, as I created an account just for this and it has no followers. If someone could do something like that that would be great (i have no idea how any of this works sorry)
auskgd
I will now go and try to rest a little before I get up for work again. Thanks everyone for the help and advice earlier.
Hello everyone\. I created this account to publicly address and respond to Cliqueโs thread, to contextualize everything, clear things up and apologize for the harm I caused\.
https://t.co/mvGNqk3tHp
It's 3:44 am and I'm still at work because I was typing this. I am so exhausted. But it's finally done.
August 12, 2026
gecko4
itโs evident heโs not transphobic and thatโs what his response is going to hopefully tell everybody (edited)
gecko4
definitely not pointless the stuff he said was pretty harmful and from an outside perspective a very valid concern
sakura.eve
all this being said, just wanna be clear i lowkey didn't read into any of the drama regarding ausk, all i know is from what was said in this channel about it, like i didn't even read your response (sorry) just felt like pointless drama cuz like, from what you're saying i sincerely doubt you're transphobic ๐ญ
ivyteal_
it is very bad to say but i don't think that's obvious to a person who isn't that informed on the topic of trans people
sakura.eve
i think transphobia has to stem from some sort of hate or intolerance, and i don't think being concerned for your friend counts as transphobia, that just means you need to become a little more educated to their situation, which i assume happened between you and Clique
auskgd
But who am I to say... I clearly have approached things wrongly as well
That's so like Not what you should Do
auskgd
๐ญ
sakura.eve
me personally i didn't reach out to any of my friends like i was struggling i was just like "yo im trans now" and one of them started sending me church resources to help and i'm like "okay can you not"
yeah i think you're fine that makes a lot of sense why you handled it the way you described
auskgd
Thank you for your kindness Sakura. I really appreciate it.
Also, just a small clarification about this:
> had friends who reached out to me about my transition assuming i was struggling cuz thats just how religions function
Clique explicitly said she was struggling and opened up, which is why the topic branched into that in the first place, it wasn't based on an assumption.
sakura.eve
i personally think it's up to the individual to express "hey i don't like being called dude can you not"
mbed
whats up dudettes
sakura.eve
ik dudette a word but who out here saying dudette be so fr
doesn't feel like there's a gender behind dude
also i have used dude as a gender neutral term A LOT cuz it just feels like a word
i havenโt read into the full details of what happened ausk but i lowkey donโt hold anything against you personally, when i was religious i had friends who reached out to me about my transition assuming i was struggling cuz thats just how religions function, i dont think youre transphobic based on what you said and i think trying to paint you as transphobic is wrong, like itโs clear youโre trying to not offend people and my very limited talking with you (like i think iโve sent 3 messages to you and they were yesterday) itโs clear youโre a good person
gecko4
i use "girl" in the same way and had to apologise for using it on a guy ๐ญ (edited)
auskgd
I understand that now. I'm sorry.
auskgd
Sounds good. I will try to include that in my document.
ravingrafters
This last bit to me is a little bit worrisome, however. More specifically, the fact that the way its phrased feels like a "I want to talk to a different person" which, simultaneously acknowledges their chosen identity, but does pretty much exclusively read as dismissive of it. But again, it's a point that Ausk specifically mentioned themselves and owned up to it, with intent to be better. My personal thoughts is that this isn't really something that I feel is okay regardless of context, but, I also do not feel was with malicious intent, either, and given that the thought process was already explained, any sort of response to such I feel needs to elaborate further into that exact thought process, and the realization afterwards. Basically, have to acknowledge everything or you may as well acknowledge nothing. Anything left out becomes fuel for the fire, even stuff that may have otherwise been inconsequential. As far as the rest is concerned, I'll likely keep any remaining thoughts to myself until things develop further.
auskgd
Tbh I am not that worried about convincing most people. Especially people that like cancel culture and hating on others. They never cared about me, already hate me now regardless of what I reply and without knowing me, and will continue to hate me until they forget about me in 2 weeks. My concern is with the harm I accidentally caused, the people that actually know me, and with the fact Clique intentionally framed this the worst way possible as if I was actively hating on her or trans people.
arcanin
thereโs no context where it would make it ok to be said
1kreno
i dont know if im not picking up on something, but i personally still dont see what the explaination for "who you were made" is, this doesnt get explained by "shes a friend struggling with religion", if anything i think this is the last thing to say to someone like that
hychie
its hard though yeah, i understand where ausk is coming from because i grew up in a very religious area, so im familiar that thought process
hychie
i feel like its explained alright here in the second point
kazvixx
it took a while to explain here
its almost impossible lol
liathecat
but youre gonna need to word a response to that pretty damn well to convince most ppl
i understand what youre saying now
auskgd
I wouldn't say that to a stranger
It's just cooked if out of context
auskgd
.
liathecat
do you have an explanation for what you actually meant by that ausk or is it just super cooked ๐ญ
i was just reading the messages just sent here i didnt see the initial context
auskgd
I don't think anyone is focusing on that
arcanin
yea idk why weโre focusing on the โdudeโ part when thatโs clearly not the issue here
liathecat
ah i see
auskgd
This @Lia (edited)
liathecat
wheres the context youre referring to i cant find it
auskgd
I don't think anyone was ignoring that. Since the beginning I was shown to be wrong and have been taught on how that's actually a big deal, which I was ignorant of
g.ben
not at all the important part from how i see it, thats just how the sentence went so i'd assume thats why mag included it. For me the most concerning part is the second half and again, what im seeing is everyone kinda just ignores it and gets hung up on the not very significant stuff... Am I really missing something because i feel like noone seems to be concerned about anything that was said, even now that Ausk here have said, "The second point doesn't have any justification or explanation."
ravingrafters
Also, personally speaking, I myself have only really had positive interactions with Ausk, even if its not a large pool of interactions to pull from. Only reason I bring this up is because I myself am openly trans, and not once has it ever been made a point of discussion, so I'm more willing to believe that it was not intended to harm or belittle, even if it has had this impact, just based on personal experience. To me this feels more like a mistake, one of which Ausk has openly admitted and earned up to, with clear intent to improve going forward. I at least feel like, if Ausk was in fact just outright transphobic, even if it wasn't openly stated, the actual vibe of any of the discussions we had would be less pleasant and honestly instead just "off" in a way that would be tricky to convey. Like, more standoff-ish, if that makes sense.
Again, do not wish to excuse any of it, but wanted to put some of my own thoughts out there I suppose, and part of why I approached this situation from the start with a grain of salt.
auskgd
Just mentioning this to explain that the pronoun stuff isn't the issue at hadn, but rather how I dismissed her identity, which I now understand is wrong (edited)
But not using that as justification of what I said. I said what I said and there is no way around it. It was still dismissive and inconsiderate
auskgd
Also, unrelated, but Clique specifically said she's fine with any pronouns
devilmine
๐ฅ
and do the same
devilmine
i use bro too often
kazvixx
imagine them making an exposal post few months after
liathecat
its not a big deal personally but i understand why it might affect others
ironically enough i literally just dmd a female friend and said bro in the message
i use 'dude' 'man' and 'bro' to literally anyone
auskgd
Can I send it here for you guys to take a read before I post? It would greatly help
auskgd
Perhaps I should include something more like this in my doc before I post it.
kazvixx
but that's exactly what i thought on the situation
its extremely hard to explain to people with a different mentality
auskgd
I'll split this into two parts: The "dude" and "man" is mannerism inherited from my mother tongue. It is common in Portuguese to mainly use the masculine words "mano" and "cara" to refer to everyone, which translate to "dude" and "man". That's why I apologized for saying those words all the time and said it's how I talk. You can notice this during my streams. I call even my fiancรฉe "dude" and "bro" sometimes, for instance.
The second point doesn't have any justification or explanation. But if giving the context helps, because of our past friendship and knowing Clique was a christian back then, I was approaching the conversation as a talk with a friend who is struggling with their faith. Not someone that completely left and didn't want to talk about these things. This openness was reinforced by the fact she opened up and said she was struggling, rather "I am no longer a christian and don't want to talk about that".
Aside from that context, That's a valid point and it was extremely inconsiderate for me. I didn't realize it would be something so harmful to her at the time, given the context. (edited)
devilmine
i agree with mbed
mbed
he clearly wants to learn from his shortcomings
kirichux3
ya mbed is right
mbed
it doesnt excuse the actions but i wouldnt go so far as to call ausk transphobic
๐
1
arcanin
Iโm not sure this excuse anything tho
mbed
it doesnt mean you believe stuff if you are misinformed
like
g.ben
?
mbed
people like to conflate things
i believe this is what happened
you can do transphobic actions without being transphobic as an individual (edited)
โ๏ธ
1
ravingrafters
Oh for sure, and Im not trying to imply that you are. I apologize if it reads as such.
kazvixx
but calling someone transphobic means that in my eyes
Im not justifying trans hate by religion
i mean ausk never shown hate towards trans people
magboom.
I was just confused about the parts โI'm sorry for saying dude and man, thats just how I talk, I know you go by she/her now but I'd like to talk to the Clique, the Clique you were made." I found it quite difficult to interpret this, and I donโt see a context where this is acceptable to say
auskgd
James 2:8-10: If you really keep the royal law found in Scripture, โLove your neighbor as yourself,โ you are doing right. But if you show favoritism, you sin and are convicted by the law as lawbreakers.
Treating people equally regardless of their beliefs
auskgd
Ye there are multiple verses with that same concept
ravingrafters
Please forgive me if I'm wrong, as Im very unfamiliar with the tenets of most religions, given that I was raised in a household that was aggressively anti-religion (I myself have gotten a lot better about that, but admittedly my 2020 self was much the same), but isn't there literally a verse in the Christian Holy Bible that says something along the lines that, to cast your own judgement on someone else is to, oneself, sin? Kind of an extension of a "love thy neighbor" sort of thing? At least, that is my understanding, and as such, I personally would not make an assumption off of someone's faith alone. Although tbf, my read of what mag said is moreso in direct response to the last bit of Kaz's line: "...than showing open hate towards a group of people." I.e: If you openly hate people, that's that, regardless of circumstance or justification. But, I also don't know if I'm completely misreading mag on that, do think it could have been phrased more clearly.
magboom.
yeah that is not what I meant at all, I obviously do not believe that every christian is transphobic
devilmine
๐ญ
yeah not a fan of that one
zhenmuron
Ye id like some clarification
gormuck
I don't think that's what mag is trying to say
zhenmuron
Yeah I agree that is a pretty large generalization to make
auskgd
Yes I was very stupid with how I said what I said, but it was out of ignorance on how to approach and be there for them and it was in the context of faith, which Clique took advantage of to portray me as hateful towards trans people which I am not
auskgd
Wdym by that? I have no hatred nor dislike towards people because they are trans, that is irrational. I was talking to an old friend about our faith. If you are not in the faith, what you do with your live is your business. I would never go to a random stranger that is trans and say "hey you shouldnt do that". The context here is completely different and I have cleared that up in the document I have written. By your definition, everyone that is a christian or a muslim would be transphobic, which is a crazy generalized affirmation and actually religious discrimination. Just as much discrimination as if I said all trans people are this or that. That indeed would be transphobia. (edited)
magboom.
imo doesnโt change the fact that you believe in something that does not accept trans people
kazvixx
W channel points remain
devilmine
And I wasn't referencing that so the overstating part in that argument would still apply to what I specifically meant
To be fair tho it is not what I was aware off
ravingrafters
Im moreso just clarifying, because I do feel that its not overstating it and I wanted the context to be a bit more available. Don't intend to shit on anybody, nor am I looking to get anybody in any further trouble or anything. Also why Im kind of just not saying anything to this discussion.
devilmine
Clarification was much needed and I'm glad its there
as i was thinking about it
Its funny cuz i also wanted to reach out later today prob about it
zhenmuron
Yeah and more clarification was definitely needed so Iโm glad you and others reached out
devilmine
Yeah I figured
zhenmuron
Weโve already spoken to both
I also donโt know what benefit dunking on these two does here
kazvixx
When u speak with a friend who has been religious for a while and u had religious talks with them, speaking with them from the side of religion is different than showing open hate towards a group of people
devilmine
"I hate minorities" vs "I didn't understand it properly and said some harmful stuff accidentally as a result" but maybe thats just me
ravingrafters
Idk about that. Most people are familiar with the bits thing, but this was an option added to the site Tri made, even if, to my knowledge, nobody ever used it, including Tri himself. This is what prompted me to ask autonick for more clarification just for my own peace of mind.
๐ผ๏ธ
image.png
16.26 KB
Local
sakura.eve
call me crazy but i think following accounts that post sexual artwork of underaged characters is worse than sending levels donated to you
zryder_
Yeah the Tricipital thing isnโt on nearly the same level
zhenmuron
Not good but not comparable to the other shit here imo
zhenmuron
The way that it worked was through a donation anyone in the chat could semi randomly get a minute boost to odds of being seen (edited)
agsilver.
Not it
Hearing the way things were stated, im appauled im sorry. Even if it was with good intention the shit said was just
devilmine
Idk I feel like there is a fine line of
magboom.
im sure I dont have to detail why is it wrong
devilmine
Rather just unintentionally/unaware
arcanin
especially with the stuff that was said too
magboom.
transphobic is transphobic
devilmine
Its not that either
devilmine
The last one is what it boils down to me and is my stance still
magboom.
does it matter whether one is publicly or privately transphobic? why is that important
devilmine
Publicly transphobic was wrong and I corrected it
devilmine
Monetizing it kinda was what happened to some degree as an element of money was added to requesting levels with more priority
zhenmuron
Understating*
Accidentally following accounts is understanding it
devilmine
Ultimately its what it boils down to as others mentioned that they didn't think she is a bad person lowk
zhenmuron
Publicly being transphobic is overstating it
Monetizing requests is overstating it
sakura.eve
minimizing it to accidentally followed accs when itโs SUPER BAD is downplaying
devilmine
but ykwim
Or not publicly transphobic
Mod accidentally being publicly transphobic and one monetizing requests vs someone having accidentally followed accs ๐ญ
arcanin
I believe so too
sakura.eve
i lowkey disagree
devilmine
I lowkey agree
agsilver.
Personally think the other 2 dramas lowkey are worse than the one that actually got the worst punishment but thats just me (edited)
devilmine
Punishment doesn't have to be demotion
We dont know if there was behind the scene stuff tho
arcanin
idk itโs weird that only in one case has actual punishment been served (edited)
devilmine
despite it all nailing down to huge mistakes
Everyone made a mistake and everything was handled a bit differently but also just with different punishments in a way
relicsong
it's just so tiring and frustrating bruh
I want to mention that I have no hatred towards any of the 3 who have gotten into dramas; I just want there to be consistency and justice man, emphasis on consistency
sakura.eve
it was about ausk until then
dreameatergd
Well Twitter does have a mind of its own, despite how much I try to distance myself from the GD side of it there's definitely been some debate on both ausk and the money thing
sakura.eve
this is because devilmine posted yraxs response doc
sakura.eve
i agree with this too, plenty of people draw adults just follow them
devilmine
I mean the third one also found a conclusion in form of the rule change
giggsrh
I don't even know what the third one is ๐ญ
Yea the Ausk one has kinda reached a temporary conclusion
devilmine
and quite frankly we have to see what happens when ausk puts out the document
Tbf the ausk thing was talked a lot about already
agsilver.
Ur right
relicsong
as well
but we have 2 other elephants in the room
like of course we can talk about yrax stuff, not saying we can't at all
swtcyn
mbmb
Okay thought so.
agsilver.
yea
swtcyn
I forget what ie. means. ๐ญ It's example right?
relicsong
and the other 2 issues are seemingly swept under
it really bothers me how every time i check here it's just yrax
there needs to be some consistency here with how we treat how mods may act in the public eye
arcanin
^
relicsong
3 active mod related dramas yet only one is prioritised and it seems noone gaf about the other 2
it's all so tiring
devilmine
Definitely the best play ๐ญ
howard_subwoofer
i would go as far as to say dont follow things that depict children period
1
imdrane
i avoid it like the plague

zryder_
My life so happy when I donโt use Twitter ๐ฅฐ
zhenmuron
Fr
zryder_
Realistically speaking Iโm not policing follows just donโt follow porn on main and especially those that depict children (edited)
zhenmuron
ie. porn
zhenmuron
Yeah this but we are more strict about stuff that requires no context to understand
imdrane

iโll check my stuff later today
ok makes sense
gecko4
i think the focus is on anything you wouldnt want a young person finding via your followed tab
imdrane
for example
i think i might still follow efext
or should we check for problematic people too
is it only nsfw stuff that maintenance recommends us to unfollow
devilmine
like holy shit ๐ญ
devilmine
yeah bro
imdrane
good luck to her
imdrane
holy ๐ญ
devilmine
and having followed like 1k ppl is pretty fried then
There is the possibility those accounts were followed pre mod too and were forgotten about
like keep in mind
gecko4
cus she was pretty popular on twitter (almost 10k followers) and for a while would follow anyone that followed her
devilmine
๐ญ
especially with how unexcusably dogshit twitters performance is on both the app and browser
gecko4
supa followed like EVERYONE back back in 2023-2024 times and since then just never cleared out i think
devilmine
but im trying to just make the point that following a lot of people can make combing through REALLY fucking hard and time intensive
its a lot i agree
swtcyn
Okay that's just... excessive though no?
devilmine
half a decade
keep in mind, the accounts existed for like
and they took like 12 hours to comb out like 15-20% of it iirc from what they told me
5000 followed accs
and unfollowing stuff
she has been going though her social media followings because of this
Ive been talking to Supacluck about it
i mean ngl
its lowkey so forgettable its insane
gormuck
to be fair she follow almost 900 account, while you could argue it's skill issue i still think it's harsh to say it's a lack of care
devilmine
till i remembered one day and just deleted it
i did too
gecko4
can confirm i forgot bluesky itself even existed LOL
devilmine
literally just forgot the account existed prob ๐ฅ
keep in mind that the inactivity period was also before any drama previously even came out
๐ญ
lowkey if u forgot the acc existed basically
zhenmuron
Just speaks to further lack of care
zhenmuron
No it isnโt imo
gecko4
jkrt2 has 44 mutuals with me and the person above has 4 (edited)
mbed
even if you dont follow them
i think thats how it establishes connection
do people you follow follow the others at the top
gecko4
it's very out of order for me
๐ผ๏ธ
image.png
117.45 KB
Local
zhenmuron
Cuz mobile
devilmine
so like IDK
according to herself
yeah and that one is the only one she found too
zhenmuron
I canโt check the others
devilmine
suggestive accs would be still vastly different ๐ญ
zhenmuron
1 for sure cub acc on twitter
devilmine
3 cub accs?
zhenmuron
Iโm on mobile sorry lol
I think maybe it was 4
zhenmuron
Twitter only shows a small portion of the total and we found 3
mbed
i think
but if you have none its recent
devilmine
seems like it
mbed
iirc
it prioritizes accounts you have connection with at the top (edited)
devilmine
so it definitely just is that behavior as mentioned tbh
followers and following tab is the exact same for me on top to bottom
its like
so lol
but its the same anyways
wrong tab actually
kirichux3
yeas
liathecat
ic
gecko4
but not others
i think it shows you your own follows chronologically
liathecat
so idk
mine shows them chronologically
devilmine
๐
she definitely didnt follow me just today
this is not true
๐ผ๏ธ
image.png
12.54 KB
Local
liathecat
these would almost certainly have been new follows
and i can only assume they were checked in that order
well thats the thing because on twitter when you view someones follows it shows them chronologically newest to oldest
howard_subwoofer
6 months is lowkey not a big enough difference for me
devilmine
1 is guaranteed not on twitter
thats something to consider too
bluesky was inactive for 6 months
cuz again
how many were on twitter
tbh though
its 6 accounts
kirichux3
i really doubt that
kirichux3
i cant in good faith believe this ill be fr
devilmine
and again with everything WE know here
devilmine
Was never made sure, never was communicated
devilmine
I wouldnt and I wouldve argued equally as much here
liathecat
and there could well have been way more
devilmine
that fell under that rlly
6 total accounts that they have confirmed looked at
devilmine
suggestive accounts too was 3 before they stopped looking
liathecat
i got warned too for just following suggestive/nsfw accounts and if i got demoted that same day i would have seen it as absolutely jusitifiable
kirichux3
when it said multiple accounts it was unclear how many were cub, how many there were even in total, etc
liathecat
2 or 3 too many
gecko4
they made it sound like it was tons of accounts and it was 2 or 3
kirichux3
wasnt
liathecat
i thought it was clear it was more than one account from the initial first dm pauze sent her
devilmine
yeah
kirichux3
especially when not involved
if ppl find it frustrating or annoying it is 100% fine to not engage in it
i see no issue
its a complicated situation which needs a lot of discussion to get to the bottom to
kirichux3
theres been a lot found out and a lot learned from these back and forths, we found out it was more than 1 account, and we also got a bit more clarity
liathecat
nothing will change i just think its pointless
devilmine
๐ ๐ ๐
that a lot of ppl here would antivouch because of her reputation and other stuff they mentioned behind her back right after she got demoted
liathecat
what are we even arguing for here
โ๏ธ
1
devilmine
I also see the issue of the fact that if she tried to reapply
liathecat
i guess im just frustrated at every week or so theres a new drama that results in days of back and forth and 90% of the time nothing ever changes
devilmine
To be completely fair though
gecko4
nobody denies she was reckless as hell to let that stuff on her follows it's just nuanced
devilmine
speaking from experience
like she has always been SO careful of stuff
ngl
Knowing her probably the best from anyone here
gecko4
yea i can understand why many go with demotion as the correct route i'm just on the warning side also
devilmine
considering everything I know about the person as well
i just heavily lean towards warning being 1000% the better play here personally
yeah it just is a fundamental different view
kirichux3
its just different viewpoints on how to handle it
I honestly dont see the side of a demotion or a warning to be wrong in any way
kirichux3
i dont really understand being frustrated at the backlash rather than just understanding how both sides are very valid in their thought process of it
devilmine
like generally speaking
it would just do no harm to reach out talk about stuff first when it comes to potential demotion reasons and lock them out of here
even if during that time u take permissions to read chat/send messages of the server
even outside of this i think its just a more respectful approach and would also prevent a lot of issues
Id really appreciate if stuff is being talked out first or communicated to people before falling a full decision too
To be completely honest though realistically outside of this
dreameatergd
I am taking this one
dreameatergd
LOL
devilmine
holy
thats a name i forgot till now
devilmine
oh god bro
dreameatergd
Crazy stuff
dreameatergd
I had 1 still (Ava Kris Tyson)
devilmine
early follows from when I made my account
๐
I checked mine and I followed like 2 groomers
dreameatergd
Like, I just checked my followed accounts today and there's nothing bad but what if there was
liathecat
ive kept myself detached from this discussion entirely due to it frustrating me, but i must say that while it may be unfair on her part due to not intend to follow accounts posting that content the demotion was 100% justifiable and admittedly im pretty frustrated and disappointed in the amount of backlash the demotion got (edited)
arcanin
thats my issue
idk what ausk did is also unmod worthy yet nothing will happen
devilmine
๐ฅ
in this matter too
and u can see it by how many ppl support her
even though she literally has been doing her best to fix her reputation
yeah
gormuck
I agree
arcanin
๐ญ
i still think it feels like that
devilmine
it partially felt like a scapegoat to some degree to get her of the team to me due to how her reputation was rocky (while she still was actively improving it no matter where she could)
dreameatergd
Plus it's not really a daily routine to comb through followed accounts just to avoid any accidents like this
devilmine
if u dont even think she is a bad person at all?
devilmine
I guess so but wouldnt that even more play into favor of saying "accident happened, very hard hit on the shoulder and if it happens again ur gone"
dreameatergd
It's plausible that someone may have followed an account so long ago
I'll play devil's advocate for a moment but keep in mind I'm sure most people have had their social media accounts active for an incredibly long time
devilmine

devilmine
not beating the elder mod accusations smh
sakura.eve
oh shit i do too
zryder_
Itโs 8:42 I need to shower ๐ญ
zhenmuron
Yeah
sakura.eve
i donโt think anyone thinks yrax is a bad person, i just think she is careless with her follows which is super concerning as mod
zhenmuron
Yeah
zhenmuron
^ this is why we did it the way we did
zryder_
Like idk I donโt think Yrax is a bad person or a pedo or smth
devilmine
when there is ALOT of reasonable plausibility of it being a mistake
wouldve this issue ever cropped up again
sakura.eve
people die over accidents
in the real world if you make a big mistake you arenโt gonna get an โah shucks, it happens! see you tomorrowโ like people get fired over accidents
devilmine
I really want you to go through this and just explain what wouldve been the issue of telling her "Yo, unfollow and if we catch u again u are booted off"
zryder_
Just to have all the information there, remember we didnโt actually say anything about it initially. Just left it as a resignation and moved on
devilmine
as i even provided earlier
as again the account uploaded shit outside of it too
The tolerance being of a genuine possible mistake
zhenmuron
I think any tolerance of it is dangerous and irresponsible
devilmine
๐ฅ
why was it mentioned ontop of that
sakura.eve
the thing is if it was only like 1 then it could realistically be seen as an accident and shouldnโt have been so harsh, like she didnโt mean to follow that account or smth
devilmine
But then like why was it mentioned to her that its especially concerning because of it
zhenmuron
If any of you followed cub porn id want you unmodded straight up
zryder_
Well idk what else to say, it just wasnโt
zhenmuron
Not the decision
As Ryder said it is icing on the cake
devilmine
I dont know I cant help but feel like her past false accusations were taken into account when doing this decision regardless of what was said especially with how frequently it was mentioned
1kreno
i dont think we should reason with "it was only XY cub accounts" it sounds so bad im sorry
zhenmuron
Of the cub stuff no but itโs still nasty
devilmine
correct?
like straight porn
so the rest isnt nsfw
the one u showed too was apparently the worst it got
sakura.eve
gotcha
devilmine
again like
zhenmuron
Gecko is correct ya
gecko4
pauze said 2/3 were cub and the other 3 were regular suggestive/nsfw accs
sakura.eve
i agree
zryder_
I still think it should be 0 tolerance on it
sakura.eve
they stopped at 6, and iโm sorry but following 4 sexual cub accounts is 4 too many
zryder_
But whether they accused her or not
Itโs cub porn the allegations atp are like frosting. It definitely doesnโt help if you already been accused of messing with underage people to be also following cub
gecko4
for cub stuff it was 2/3 accounts apparently
devilmine
You just said "especially given her past allegations"
zhenmuron
But it speaks to the bigger problem
It wasnโt part of the decision
devilmine
and a warning wouldve been enough in that case
Yes I can
as they were fully debunked as a nothing burger
zhenmuron
Ok but as someone who has people combing her socials you can understand why being careless matters surely
devilmine
in a decision like this
or is even inclusive
and should NOT been something that a decision is made off
sakura.eve
like 1 can be an accident, but 6+ is negligence and should be punished and she was
gormuck
isn't twitch age limited anyway ?
devilmine
quite frankly
devilmine
the allegations shouldnt come to play
mrspaghetti
Are you sure
zhenmuron
You need to be more on top of it and more responsible Iโm sorry
gormuck
no
sakura.eve
you ever do a level request stream?
gormuck
but ig it make sense
zhenmuron
I think we just fundamentally see the severity of this differently, I have zero tolerance for this ESPECIALLY given how much we have been through as a team and especially given her past allegations
gormuck
Idk I don't really think we interact with child a lot anyway
sakura.eve
the fact gd is a kids game makes it extra concerning that a mod of that kids game follows accounts posting sexual images of child like characters, itโs like being okay with someone smoking in the firework factory
zhenmuron
Yes
devilmine
i assume u did
did u check if those other accs change their content too over time?
that seems like an accident if anything
yeah
zryder_
Some others just had general nsfw accounts, nothing child like and they just got warns
zhenmuron
Other 3 nsfw
devilmine
so bruh
gormuck
children don't use twitter
gormuck
while I agree it's concerning I don't think it should matter at all that gd is a children game
zhenmuron
2/3 had suggestive cub adjacent stuff one I canโt open on twitter on mobile cuz I donโt have it
zryder_
A couple were cub and others NSFW/suggestive accounts in general. The one that is referenced is very likely the worst of them all that was found. Even if it were just only, I believe we should be 0 tolerance on it
sakura.eve
thatโs too much for me to consider an simple accident personally
zhenmuron
6 accounts before we stopped looking
sakura.eve
i can only assume itโs a lot based on yrax being uncomfortable enough by some of her follows to purge some herself before she was warned, if sheโs only unfollowing the ones making it to her timeline whatโs that say about the ones not on her timeline, surely not all of them made it to her timeline before she was warned, like, maintenance wouldnโt have demoted her if she followed 1 account like that
devilmine
and atm im more inclined believing my close friend than anything
that she unfollowed
yrax told me herself she found 1 on twitter
but again
i would be more inclined towards it and be siding with this demotion if it was like 20 cub accs or some shit
kirichux3
you cant draw conclusions like that from 1
but
1 would obv still be bad
a lot would make me like 10000% side with the demotion no questions asked
devilmine
^^
kirichux3
the real difference here is if it actually is a lot or not though
devilmine
a lot yeah
sakura.eve
a mistake like that is super dire when youโre in a position like mod in a childrenโs game
iโm sorry but if you randomly follow a lot of accounts posting nsfw cub youโre negligent and should be punished
devilmine
๐ญ
id personally say that its not even interacting to just follow an account as it is to like or retweet shit
devilmine
interacting is such a stretch though if it was a random follow with nothing beyond that
sakura.eve
she said in her response she unfollowed multiple accounts that ended up on her timeline posting stuff like that, so iโm willing to assume thereโs was many
zhenmuron
I think that interacting with cp or anything adjacent to it is about the worst thing you can do as a mod before grooming
devilmine
at least thats what I got personally told
rest was suggestive stuff
Yrax told me she found acc on twitter that she thinks would fit into this
devilmine
I will say
sakura.eve
iโve been as harsh as iโve been because i assume thereโs been a lot of cub accounts, just based on what iโve read here and what yrax said in her response
gecko4
if theres only one example of actual cub art itโs much more likely itโd just be an accident
cus other mods were just warned for following that other stuff
sakura.eve
thatโs a good question
devilmine
that would arguably change it ALOT
gecko4
i was just wondering if โmany accountsโ referred to cub specifically or just other suggestive/nsfw accounts as a whole
sakura.eve
and i imagune that someone was on maintenance (edited)
devilmine
yeah
sakura.eve
from his understanding implies someone said there was a ton
devilmine
and we dont know what prompted that
devilmine
from his understanding iirc
devilmine
according to me having asked here before
sakura.eve
hado said a few days back that it was super frequent, like you could find one in 15 seconds frequent
devilmine
apparently there were on her twitter
gecko4
we only have one account example and iโm skeptical of there being further examples is all
is it prying too much to ask for a second example account for the cub stuff? because itโs being used as there being so many more examples of it and iโm just wondering how bad the other ones are and if there was a higher density of normal posts from them to reasonable follow for
gormuck
๐ฝ
devilmine
๐ญ
iirc
the viprin retweet was a loli in a beach suit on a beach
zryder_
The Viprin retweet (edited)
gecko4
i dont remember how explicit it was idt it was nsfw
zryder_
Idr the exact details but I think it was suggestive?
gormuck
lmao bruh I wasn't aware
zryder_
I mean following is a pretty big interaction too imo
kirichux3
I think everyone here is in agreeance that viprin should have resigned/should have been demoted, but its pretty obvious why he didnt get demoted (who is going to demote him)
devilmine
(no content)
๐ผ๏ธ
image.png
29.33 KB
Local
sakura.eve
i heard it a lot lately apparently he retweeted loli on main ๐
gecko4
he did once evidently while signed into the wrong account
gormuck
viprin was retweeting loli art ?
sakura.eve
he just decided to not demote himself
gecko4
thats why ppl are bringing that up
sakura.eve
i think viprin shouldโve been demoted for this
gecko4
i think itโs more on the relevance of viprin directly retweeting it and yrax never interacting beyond the follow button
zryder_
But idk man, I feel like if people found out about it first it woulda been different
sakura.eve
if it was one account iโd agree, but this accident is a really massive accident that happened over and over again when itโs more than 1 account, it sounds like there where several, not including the ones she mentioned she unfollowed on her own before hand
zryder_
Iโm kinda surprised that people bring up loli art and cub art and say one is fine over the other
sakura.eve
he did an internal investigation on himself and felt that he was good to stay mod ๐ญ
zryder_
Prolly just lucky that they reported instead of just going on Twitter first
zryder_
Some non mod reported about the Yrax thing so I wouldnโt say it wasnโt public persay
devilmine
I rather feel weird about the fact that one mistake that is a plausible accident can get u immediately demoted with no communication and not even looking at stuff
sakura.eve
if weโre talking about viprin he shouldโve been demoted years ago but he was the king
arcanin
it was less about her reputation and more so about how inconsistent those punishments feel
sakura.eve
which is why i didnโt mention her reputation once
sakura.eve
i personally think her reputation prior to this doesnโt matter, i think this on its own is grounds for demotion
sakura.eve
iโm sorry for being harsh but this is a kids game and NONE OF US or anyone for that matter should follow anything that posts sexual images of child like characters, thatโs EXTREMELY inappropriate, accidents happen but if you accidentally follow lots of accounts that post that shit, thatโs just negligence
arcanin
i will say this: i completely understand why she would get demoted for this, even for an accident. but i do not like that other mods that also are in controversy and that are hurting the reputation of the mod team allowed to stay while not getting repercussions for those accidents too (edited)
devilmine
as said by herself
this isnt being reduced to one acc
devilmine
> Some of the things found included nsfw/suggestive furry art and cub art,
sakura.eve
there was more than one account, another problem i have with yraxs response and the way the public are reacting to it, there wasnโt a single problem account
devilmine
the account in question posted had multiple months where they didnt post shit at all or do stuff (edited)
at all
u dont see that shit easily
devilmine
wdym
sakura.eve
that is just not excusable imo
if it was 1 i can give her a bit of a pass like jesus but like unfollow that i can see it being an accident you didnโt realize or know yet, but she had already seen multiple account she follow post that stuff and then anonymous mods found lots more
following multiple accounts sexually depicting child like characters is a big mistake (edited)
some accidents are too far right off the bat
devilmine
so like
devilmine
I mean I think that is fair but it was the first accident that was brought to her attention with that matter
sakura.eve
hereโs my harsh take: if an accident keeps happening it goes from an accident to just plain negligence. After the second or third account she shouldโve been like โoh shit this keeps happening i should scrub my followsโ. People get punished for accidents in the real world all the time, you donโt just get a freebie cuz itโs an accident, this is a massive mistake and if what she said is true this makes me feel like itโs just pure negligence she didnโt purge sooner (edited)
devilmine
i just dont get it ๐ฅ
like
again this completely rules out it not being an accident (edited)
she always said this
gecko4
yea was gonna say hasnโt she always tried to stay on top of this stuff in the past
dreameatergd
I just went through my followed accounts on Twitter... Almost 800 turned into less than 700 which is still a lot but at least none of them are NSFW
devilmine
๐ฅ
imma be real
which makes this even more irrational as not being an accident
even publicly before pretty sure
theyll unfollow immediately
howard_subwoofer
My b
Oh nah i wasnt tryna say that
devilmine
again, they mentioned before multiple times to tell them if they follow bad stuff
which they are not
It sounds like u implied them being public about liking this stuff
howard_subwoofer
Not to say they privately do
Well thats what would happen theyd stop publicly following accounts like that
devilmine
As this is again a plausible accident
I feel like thats a whole seperate issue
๐ญ
We shouldnt open up that can of worms
They are not into this
howard_subwoofer
I mean theyd probably stop being public about that kind of stuff
devilmine
it WASNT public info and this "liability" wouldve been fixed with communication in this scenario
gormuck
^
devilmine
it was completely private in mod circles
what wouldve happened in the future?
someone went to her, told her "yo dont follow that stuff, very bad"
devilmine
yeah but again think about it like this
devilmine
I just cannot comprehend why communication wouldn't have worked here
howard_subwoofer
It was a precaution that was taken cuz people have blown up over this sorta stuff before
kirichux3
im still conflicted on whether I agree or not with the demotion, but that point would be the same regardless of a demotion or not
devilmine
^^
arcanin
you could remake the world with what ifs
kirichux3
TBH i dont think this holds up cus this can also just be fixed with a theoretical harsh warning
orots
which i agree this is reckless
like out of what 3k-5k
if you follow a lot of accounts this will happen
howard_subwoofer
People are upset that they got unmodded for this but have we considered what wouldve happened if people found out they follow this account before they were unmodded
g.ben
yeah i havent seen like any of the accounts she was following so im just assuming things
orots
few out of a lot but similarly yrax apparently had very few nsfw accounts in their following
devilmine
same degree of carelessness
who also followed bad stuff without checking even if its not to the same degree
like other ppl
it is but again nothing a harsh warning wouldve fixed
hychie
it feels so careless to not check even a little bit
gecko4
the account did not market itself as such iirc
hychie
so i realize yeah i shouldnt follow
devilmine
๐
no doubt
like
hychie
sometimes ill find great art on twitter and then check their account and its horrible
devilmine
I will clarify tho that this guy genuinely needs to go to hell
g.ben
99% of the times nsfw accounts have some sort of indication of them being one in the name idkk, if there really were multiple examples of this its hard to think it really was an accident...
hychie
right ๐ญ
devilmine
it is but a warning wouldve been clearly enough in the case of an accident of that
howard_subwoofer
Like i get that they post an occasional sfw thing but im lookin through a few posts before deciding thats the onky kind of stuff they post
orots
or if it has the age restriction thing
howard_subwoofer
I think thats foolish to do
orots
if your account generally doesnt interact with nsfw much it can push those few non nsfw tweets from bad accounts
devilmine
that are reasonable
that would literally completely make it an accident
there are at least like 3-4 posts i see
arcanin
i understand how it could be an accident
devilmine
thats the matter
^^^^^^
arcanin
i mean i have followed accounts based on one post alone
zhenmuron
One out of how many
devilmine
random art that isnt literally that
example
(no content)
๐ผ๏ธ
image.png
69.86 KB
Local
g.ben
yeah, i'd hope so
orots
im sure itll be brought up again later anyway (edited)
g.ben
from how i see it, one of them is worse, and its not the yrax one....
orots
dw
zhenmuron
๐
Iโm at work so I canโt rly get into things much atm
These are just not comparable
g.ben
exactly...
arcanin
2 other mods in controversy rn yet they'll get away with it while yrax immediately got blasted feels icky to me icl
devilmine
๐ญ
dont get me wrong
even tho that account in general was INSANELY cooked
There was normal art inbetween that doesnt even fall in that category of terrible shit
zhenmuron
???
g.ben
if reputation is the main concern, (sorry to bring it in this convo) the current Ausk situation which has video proof shouldn't really be as accepted as it is by so many people here for some reason... Like what im seeing right now is people just disregard everything Ausk said just because Clique handled the situation poorly...
devilmine
Yes very much so considering I looked at the original account that was mentioned and it wasnt exclusively suggestive art in any capacity
zhenmuron
Can we call it an accident when itโs multiple accounts and said accounts have only ever posted cub
orots
its been a bit so i do respect the final decision in the end as u can make the point about it being really reckless, if anything yrax needs the support more rn as that and other culminating shit seemed to have impacted her reallt heavily
devilmine
if u like enough that shit appears in people stuff that undoubtebly another level of carelessness
because bro what are u doing gtfo ๐ญ
if u were found out to do that SOMEHOW
liking things is not even publicly viewable and would arguably be worse
gecko4
yea fair
devilmine
not really what should matter here
like
I think thats a seperate thing
gecko4
i donโt know if this is an important clarification to make but for anyone unaware, your followers only get served posts on their timelines from tweets you like, and simply following somebody will not promote their content at all to your followers
again not sure if relevant but thought iโd mention
arcanin
i still highly believe that what happened between her and regnom played a part into how they acted immediately rather than communicate in the first place
devilmine
first at that
she wouldve gotten punished by getting a scare of it regardless with a harsh warning
its bad
with everything considered
a shit accident that is BEYOND reasonable to have happened
because again if she was told about it that entire issue wouldve been solved
g.ben
i think the main difference is that yrax was the only one where they found cub accounts, everyone else who got the warning only followed nsfw/suggestive artists
devilmine
I still think she should get repromoted genuinely
gormuck
idk it's not like she draw that kind of thing herself
devilmine
๐ญ
exactly the issue
yes
arcanin
had it been anyone but yrax there would've been communication
destriv
Imma be honest, I up until the Yrax demotion followed someone who I used to watch on YT and I hadn't seen their tweets in a while but apparently they turned to onlyfans so I unfollowed them out of fear for something similar happening to me
devilmine
arguably
orots
i think so too
devilmine
this wouldve been a permanent non issue
In a hypothetical where the was communication and a simple warning to be more careful
orots
which on its own is a pretty rough mistake
arcanin
idk many mods have made a lot more mistakes and have gotten away with it
orots
its way beyond that honestly its bordering on child-like characters, however it was completely accidentally
hychie
i just dont understand this myself because it feels so reckless
devilmine
๐ฅ
I need to highlight again that not every single post was bad and there was completely fine shit inbetween
hychie
nobodys saying shes a bad person, im sure she can eventually come back to the mod team, but i think this is a fair consequence
devilmine
Is it though? Having accounts followed that posted random stuff inbetween bad stuff in a list of 1000 followers that can easily be missed
hychie
its a pretty big mistake though
gormuck
Not being able to send level because some people you follow happen to draw art that can be uncomfortable for some people is kinda crazy idk
devilmine
having done nothing else wrong
after one mistake over a year of being mod
"u are demoted no matter what u say"
liathecat
i do agree
devilmine
literally getting dmed
like
orots
yeaa
mbed
i see many people on twitter are pointing out the hypocrisy with viprin but like, thats clearly stuff they have issues with if they are bringing it up so why is it suddenly an issue now? like we are trying to change as a team ๐ญ
orots
it just rly sucked surrounding everything regarding yraxs reputation in general
devilmine
Communication always has been an issue and continues to be prevelant
I mean I take a large issue with it that there wasnt even an attempt at communication before doing a decision
orots
i replied to this too i still disagree with the demotion but also hychie is right imo that the consequences arent unfair, after nothing happened when viprin did something similar maybe it just couldve been communicated better that there is little tolerance for it coming from maintenance (edited)
devilmine
including on an 6 months inactive account
and it was having left over follows of bad accounts by accident
๐ญ
in her entire time being mod
AT ALL
i mean this was her first time fucking up as mod
hychie
unless im missing something else
devilmine
that is fair
hychie
yeah and im saying i dont agree with that
devilmine
like
If this is actually the direct reasoning for demotion then we gotta talk man what are we doing
> **QRT\: [YraXxxxx](https://twitter.com/i/status/2087123289583853868)**
> Why I really resigned https\://docs\.google\.com/document/d/1D\-\_jGRobo5bzJt\_wEOk8j8HXedRqsYkOx8RZvaHhTrw/edit?tab=t\.0
vxTwitter / fixvxand the majority of ex mods and even public agrees with it
๐ฅ
but i still largely disagree with it being an immediate demotion as it was a pure accident from how shit works
dont disagree
gormuck
what's cub art
devilmine
definitely
hychie
๐ญ
thats still bad though
devilmine
suggestive cub art AND nsfw/suggestive art outside of that
mbed
genuinely ive been thinking the same thing
devilmine
those werent straight up porn
hychie
that they were childlike drawings
is that not what pauze was saying in modchat when she got demoted
devilmine
It was suggestive art at maximum ๐ฅ
devilmine
It wasnt cub porn that is just not True
hychie
im shocked that so many people think this is some crazy unfair punishment
kazvixx
So tri's bot should save request streaming
hychie
its kinda crazy to me that publicly admitting to following accounts that posted cub porn on her main has received such a positive response generally. i dont think shes a bad person, but this is a pretty big mistake, and i dont think the consequence of being demoted for being this careless are unfair
kazvixx
But the way u give codes is customizable
Which is clearly bad even for the older ver of rule
Ppl could increase weight for bits from what I've seen
destriv
Which is likely the reason for the rule change
I mean there was the bit donations for giving other people codes to increase weight
kazvixx
Yea
kirichux3
so its fine
kirichux3
yea but no payment involved
kazvixx
The weight system
And tri's bot still gives active people advantage
Well I guess then we hop to marbles
Shit 

devilmine
๐ฅ
so it has to go i fear
regardless
devilmine
this is also an issue
kazvixx
It seems like it doesn't change the fact that people can pay for points no matter if u get anything for it or not
g.ben
unfortunately no...
ravingrafters
Until Twitch allows people to disable boosts from bits or multipliers from subscriptions, unfortunately its all kinda set in stone as far as the earning rate goes
dreameatergd
The only way is to disable donations
kazvixx
Maybe programming people could make some sort of bot which would have own points
destriv
Can't change
No
kazvixx
Ye the point system is essential imo but is there any way to avoid getting them from bits?
destriv
This is also true
dreameatergd
Subscriptions on Twitch also give you better channel points (1.2x channel points for the entire duration of your subscription for Tier 1/Prime, 1.5x for Tier 2, 2x for Tier 3)
giggsrh
Iโve always had a request with channel points option but I turn it off during request streams because a โskip queueโ has always rubbed me the wrong way
ravingrafters
How I generally do mine is that towards the end of a req stream, I start looking through the queue for folks who I've noticed for the majority of the stream's duration, and just start pulling their levels to the front. Try to minimize that feeling of sitting in the stream for hours and just getting unlucky.
swtcyn
Can't really expect your team of mods to be there and always.
That's a pretty difficult system on it's own admittedly. (edited)
devilmine
or something
and they can dm a mod about it
have a system that chat mods check viewhours (edited)
swtcyn
Agreed with Devilmine, even if it is very slight.
ravingrafters
Realistically, the better thing to do is to end up with a different source for things like queue skips, if you still want to have them. An example would be like, say you recognize x person, they've been to several request streams back to back, but never got pulled. Nothing's stopping you from just directly asking them for the level or anything, even if it is a bit bogged down comparatively as a process.
devilmine
which is what rules should prohibit
U can spend money to skip it like that technically
g.ben
like what are really the chances that someone will find out about this and knowingly spend hundreds of dollars for 1 single request
devilmine
The possibility being there is what I take an issue with
g.ben
this is such a big thing to disregard for such an unlikely scenario tho idkkk
devilmine
not good IMO
just to request level
and then spending money on that
ravingrafters
I mostly just have rewards for goofy stuff
devilmine
imagine a kid knowing that
tbh if u can get it through bits its better not to
kirichux3
I lowkey just dont have channel point rewards for that stuff it results in people reallyyy forcing to be there
destriv
Ok yeah you can't disable the bonus channel point reward for bits
ravingrafters
Yeah unfortunately not.
orots
that sucks if true, with how customizable channel points are id expect this to be a thing the streamer can toggle
orots
that could be a problem ๐ญ
orots
oh i completely forgot about non level request related streams (edited)
ravingrafters
Nah. Thats just how twitch functions. Give bits, get points based on it. Nothing you can do to affect it, can't even change the rate
destriv
Seeing nothing so far
destriv
I'm looking if it's an option
destriv
I've noticed that people will lurk in non-req streams nowadays if a mod has a skip queue redemption to simply farm points. Joris was streaming building yesterday, and was averaging 60+ viewers with little chat activity. I nowadays get 70+ in my building streams with similar chat activity
orots
also is the bits increasing your amount of points thing something you cannot change in any twitch settings?
ravingrafters
I do personally think queue skips are probably fine, so long as they aren't behind an unreasonable amount of points, so that it feels reasonably achievable for anybody.
orots
so if theres any uptick in how many people stay throughout the entire stream it wouldnt be that huge regardless
i feel like a good chunk of people will stay during most of your stream and would become frustrated if their level hasnt been seen all this time
^
destriv
This is very true
swtcyn
I don't think it's the biggest issue in the world and it would be pretty odd if every Mod streamer suddenly disallowed skip queues.
g.ben
i've only streamed on youtube so far but from a viewer's perspective i think the channel point skip queue is a really nice thing especially when trying to get your first few rates, because its a guarantee that someone will eventually see your level no matter how unlucky you get
๐
2
ravingrafters
Yeah, most of mine have been really keen on making me play either Niwa or Universe on Fire over and over.
orots
but it is very small
it does go against the current wording in the rules tho which is sends and money interacting in any way
agsilver.
i will say, none of my twitch subs have ever used a skip queue request
kirichux3
I dont think its deep enough to disallow
orots
Finally the level request streams issue has been solved lets just not stream!
kirichux3
I have never seen anyone really do that, you would probably need to spend like $50-$100 just for 1 level request using bits -> channel points, which is kinda insane ๐ญ
destriv
Channel points are just gained over time based on how long you are in the stream. You could technically tie that directly into an incentive of being in my stream longer both gives you channel points where you can skip the queue but it also gives me more ad revenue (edited)
ravingrafters
Its not much, the bigger thing is subscriptions earning points at roughly twice the rate, so having stupidly high channel point costs slowly start inching towards wanting the subscriptions. I feel like if the channel point cost is something more reasonable, like 30k or less, it doesn't end up being a massive difference.
zhenmuron
lemme discuss with ppl and ill come back with a real answer
idk its proooobably fine
๐ฅด
almost pay for points
i didnt realize u could like
but
when we were originally discussing this we didnt have a problem with it
agsilver.
both subs and bits give you channel points, i think subs give a channel points a multiplier to earn more etc
imdrane
banning all req streams
zhenmuron
they do ye
imdrane
๐ญ
mbed
channel points feel more community centric
kirichux3
I also didnt even know bits gave channel points tbh
most people get those just by watching
I really dont think channel point redemptions are that deep. you would have to spend a LOT in bits to get your level played with just bits im pretty sure
orots
i dont know much abt twitch tho
zhenmuron
ill see what others think
orots
that also incentivizes staying longer in streams = better ad revenue i imagine
zhenmuron
idk i would avoid then tbh
destriv
I can't remember
Like 600 or so
it's not like game-changing tho
imdrane
cuz money can interact with that system
zhenmuron
i didnt know that bits gave channel points
imdrane
in that case prolly not
zhenmuron
hmmm
destriv
Giving bits does reward you with a small amount of channel points yea
kazvixx
I personally never got money from twitch cuz it's impossible for me but still can be an issue at some degree
It does not require money however from what it seems giving bits can increase the amount of points
Are we allowed to set channel points rewards for queue skip?
Also
zhenmuron
xd sorry it took so long
kazvixx
I've been waiting for that clarification since the day one being mod
Holy shit finally
devilmine
hope that went well ๐งก
auskgd
Gonna send in just a sec
Thank you
Yea I'd like that for sure
devilmine
if u want someone to make sure
I can give it another run by when ur done if u want btw
auskgd
Yesterday was my fiancรฉe's birthday, so I didn't have the time to sit on my PC and write
I was going to yesterday, but wanted to apply Devilmine's suggestions
I am about to post it
mbed
not to put pressure on u or anything
not to ignore this above but @Ausk are you planning on releasing that document? or have you already and its just within your server or something? cuz scrolling twitter today everyone is calling you transphobic and idk if this is with any response youve put out yet or not
devilmine
Just gonna mention this here because I think its important information to have
๐ฉท
2
I lowkey wanna bring this up just so people are aware, YraX came out publicly with the demotion reason ( https://x.com/YraXxxxx/status/2087123289583853868 if anyone wants to read it) and generally owns up to it as a mistake and wanting to improve despite disagreeing with what actions were taken, it seems though like the reputation issues people mentioned really mostly exists in inner less involved circles and is largely exaggerated while also a lot of the public seems to generally think that the demotion is just not fair.
That said, I'd highly urge anyone that has doubts about her and holds previous situations against her to just talk to her to build ur own opinion on matters like the previous things that were thrown around and communicate ๐ญ
August 11, 2026
gecko4
second paragraph here
gecko4
i think i read up some ppl asking for u to include or reword some stuff a bit back, idk if you have altered it since i first read it
auskgd
Do yall think the doc is good to go?
Yea
gecko4
yea iโd focus on disproving whatโs said against you and not so much what she did wrong because while it is important too you donโt want to take focus away from the core issues
auskgd
I think ill just post the apology and chill
But I dont want to make this combative
At the same time I feel like its an important part of it because it directly affects how its being perceived
I am not sure whether I should include the manipulative stuff in my doc cos it might cause her more harm and also might look like im trying to just justify myself and say I wasn't wrong etc
tricipital
i do not trust them personaly
auskgd
With all of this said, I want to thank you guys for the help, for showing i was being ignorant and for sharing the knowledge you guys did
tricipital
clique also falsely accused me of telling a viewer to kill themselves on stream
auskgd
It is honestly heartbreaking whenever I see that happening. And when realized I have accidentally caused the same effect is even more heartbreaking
auskgd
โค๏ธ thats how its supposed to be
auskgd
I'd say politics definitely have a factor. I'm not american, but from what ive seen, right-wing folk have unfortunately used the Christian name to get more votes. A similar effect happened in Brazil.
Not saying I believe in polarization, I think all sides have relevant things to bring to the table. But its just an observable phenomenon that has happened factually
sakura.eve
i do always like the ones who practice what they preach tho, cuz theyโre nice people and arenโt judgmental of me
iโm fine i found new friends, but yeahhh iโve not had a soft spot for christianity ever since, cuz i notice a lot of people who are supposed to love thy neighbor tend to hate me
auskgd
I'm very that that happened to you. Its so crazy cos thats like the opposite of what Christians should regardless of any disagreements
auskgd
That freaking sucks dude
devilmine
Im wondering if its more of an american thing because every single christian person I met irl was super nice and not like that at all here in Germany
sakura.eve
i was like great friends with a lot of christianโs when i was christian myself and in highschool, but then i came out as trans and i noticed that every single one of my friends just disappeared, i just thought they were busy with college but then i learned from a different friend that they just made a new group chat without me ๐ญ
auskgd
So online you mostly see young adults probably, and then irl its usually older folk
For the younger people I think social media gives some anonymity that makes people feel comfortable with just being hateful
auskgd
Yea unfortunately hatred / discrimination doesnt have a specific age range, it can come from anyone rly
auskgd
Dont want to worry about something that hasnt happened but I should mentally prepare for it ๐ญ
auskgd
And if anything comes up, I can look back, reflect on my mistakes, acknowledge and truly apologize sincerely and move on
sakura.eve
teenagers to young adults, like 16-22 and then older people, like 50+, there were actually a lot of respectful adults, but from my experience it was young adults and elderly
auskgd
But I guess i should focus on doing better from now on and not acting the same way.
Not to say I am not longer ignorant, I obviously have a lot to learn still ๐ญ (edited)
I'm afraid Clique might take advantage of my ignorance to dig for past instances of me saying stuff in a way that seems equally dismissive or inconsiderate, considering for how long she was planning this
auskgd
My plan is to move forward from this, yea, now with the new perspective y'all have given me
devilmine
^
auskgd
I appreciate that mbed, thank you
mbed
keep your head up king we all make mistakes and its about how we move forward after making them that defines us
๐
1
its mature to understand and accept that even if things arent your intention it doesnt remove any weight from the damage it can end up doing, and i personally believe from how youve talked about this situation that you are doing your best to educate yourself from this and have the best interests of those around you in mind
auskgd
I truly believe every human being is equal regardless of believes and should have the rights to live a secure life without being hated or discriminated. I truly believe I should love everyone as myself and i strive for that daily. But I never realized the way I talk about these things may portray the very opposite thing
To be honest, even tho it sucks and im getting really bad anxiety over it, I'm glad this happened now because it has taught me about the topic and it showed me I've been ignorant on how to address it. Even tho I only ever talk about this with friends that i think trust me and that I think i can trust to know my care for them and would never just go to someone I dont know enough to talk about this, I haven't been approaching it in a great way until now, even though in my head my approach in entirely different from people that are actually hateful, the effects can end up being the same. So it is good that this is happening, so I can reflect on the past times ive talked about this with friends and it also gives me the capacity to address these things with my friends in an actual assertive way and actually be there for them and not end up accidentally dismiss them.
devilmine
๐ญ
pretty evident it kinda sucks
Yeah they'll try to find any attacking angle and use it to hurt you
auskgd
It just keeps getting crazier. Now Clique is straight up claiming she tried reaching out to me and that I ghosted her. I don't think she knows I recorded our entire conversation before her account was suspended ๐ญ She's literally using the fact the account was suspended to just say stuff and not have to prove it
๐ผ๏ธ
image.png
463.92 KB
Local
devilmine
I definitely think that you deserve the chance as u have been a great influence for the community as a whole. This is just an unfortunate misstep and someone aiming to be as malicious as possible but that said I do still believe u should take the time and add into the document why u said some things the way u did to give an understanding of it and also give u the opportunity to reflect while typing like I suggested before, as this just really proves that you learned from it and also understand the issue at hand more right of the bat, also effectively lowering the attack angles she can take to further cause trouble
connot
ye i shouldn't take what she says at face value tbh ๐ญ
auskgd
Which is like the opposite of what she's saying here tho
connot
that's better at least
ooooh gotcha
auskgd
Also yea, Kianna was actually trying to get her to talk to me rather than going about it publicly for like months
connot
also ur fine man u rly didn't do anything crazy imo
and lol no way kiannuh is pressuring her to do this
their mental state definitely shows by releasing the audio despite concerns of her personal info getting out but also just straight up misinterpreting ur words and blowing it out of proportion
auskgd
Anyway, with all of this said, I saw some of you state that it was overblown and that I should just be more mindful/aware and to reconsider things and learn more about it, which I appreciate. I also saw some of you state that I should face harsher consequences aside from the exposure and public pressure, which I understand.
With everything in place, I'd like to ask the second group of people for another chance. I am truly sorry for what I said and the harm it caused, and from now on I will do my best to be more mindful, to truly show empathy and to not dismiss what is important to people, which I also deeply apologize for doing. Being a bit vulnerable, I absolutely love this game and I love being a moderator and being part of this team and the community, regardless of any issues. It would be an understatement to say it is a very important part of my life. Aside from this, I like to think my presence and influence in the community has been greatly positive for the past few years that I've been here, and I hope that outweights the times I fell short such as this.
I am not entitled to be forgiven by you guys or to still be accepted by the team after this, but I'd still like to ask you for that chance. Much love. (edited)
Actually, I could be remembering that wrong. Let me reword that.
auskgd
Like I mentioned, this is more something personal with me, which is fair because I was the one to say these things directly about this. But Clique wasn't/isn't in the best mental state. Iirc she was saying other things in the sense of there being creeps in the mod team etc at some point, although I don't fully remember that nor do I have an easy screenshot of it (edited)
gecko4
and iโd be surprised if they could dig up dirt on the ppl who arent as active ๐ญ
theres only like 5 or so mods i never see speak here and iโd heavily doubt anyone who does speak here would be one of them
devilmine
yeah lol
liathecat
i mean i know why he was singled out but why is nobody else namedropped at all
why single out ausk when theres a bigger issue here
im interested why nobody else was mentioned
mbed
๐ญ
liathecat
with that said
i mean obviously itd be covert
mbed
unless people have been covert about it
we have so many trans people on the mod team so....i am confused by this claim
auskgd
I preferred not to include this in my document because I did not want to end up causing more harm to Clique and I know that it might just look like I'm trying to justify the harm of what I said. I'd only add this if it turned out to be necessary.
Opening up a bit more, I'd also like to reiterate that despite knowing me for years and that I might've just been clueless and ignorant and would never say stuff towards any group out of hatred like that, Clique intentionally never pointed that out to me, never mentioned she was uncomfortable, never attempted to bring it up to me and blocked me. She also specifically attempted to manipulate multiple people into thinking I was the one that wouldn't cooperate, when I literally did not have the chance to do that because I was blocked. I've attached two images that exemplify that. I'd also like to point out she specifically mentioned she wouldn't share the video because it had personal information and proceeded to do it anyway, but that's past my point. Clique also went on a blocking streak and blocked a ton of people that had nothing to do with this incident.
Clique also just seemingly took as their personal goal to drag me. To exemplify this, many months ago, when I was in a tight spot and made a fundraiser stream for my wedding, she got into my chat and started saying "Rob Buck v2" (even though any donations were optional and didn't affect the requests at all other than making the stream longer).
Again, this is not to justify anything I did. The reason I'm stating this is to show this kind of behavior (manipulation attempts, straight up lying about a lot of stuff, blocking people that had nothing to do with this and personal vendetta) was not one instance.
auskgd
I am obviously not trying to justify anything harmful that I said, but I just want to futher contextualize on how this all came from ignorance rather than any distaste or dislike towards Clique or anyone else.
With that said, I've read what everyone suggested and I am willing to take that and improve from now on. I'd like to apologize once again to everyone that was harmed by my words. They did not come from a place of hatred. I care about Clique and continue to do so even after all this. Actually, back in February, after I was made aware that she was planning to attempt to frame this whole thing the worst way it could, I still cared and was concerned for her well being as you can see on this screenshot.
๐ผ๏ธ
image.png
372.92 KB
Local
auskgd
I appreciate this. I know my intentions weren't negative, but I also understand that doesn't change what was actually said and unfortunately interpreted, ultimately causing harm which is the very opposite of what I wanted
liathecat
but yeah id definitely recommend going and looking into it more
and again from what ive seen you had no negative intentions
I completely understand because admittedly if you don't grow up in a very left wing environment you will never truly be educated on these topics unless you experience them for yourself
auskgd
Thank you for sharing this. I admittedly don't have as much knowledge on the topic as I should, and what I intended to be just a hug saying that their struggles don't make them worse than others just ended up being dismissive and inconsiderate
This message has been redacted because it contains some form of private, personal, or identifying information that is of little to no public importance.
kazvixx
I don't think ausk should have any consequences for that, the way how this situation sparked up after a while since the first act is pretty enough for him to understand that there's no place to speak like that even with someone you consider a friend. The pressure he faces now is more than enough to be a punishment for his actions.
swtcyn
Fair, just disregard it then.
devilmine
not talking about things creates irrational and wrong assumptions while also promoting an echo chamber attitude more than not
Communication is key with everything really
Original message was deleted
polarbeahr
This sounds very much like you trying to silence people from sharing their thoughts and concerns despite, in the same message, saying you do not wish to silence anyone. Why are we supposed to just ignore it if something happens with someone in the team? If the things ausk say strike for instance me as odd or quite repulsive, am I just unreasonable for that and I should just ignore it?
agsilver.
I pretty much carry the same sentiment as spark, even if intentions were good some stuff said and done was just not right
relicsong
I will add on that I definitely agree that Rose's handling of this was, in fact, poor. However, that should not bar Ausk from accountability and consequences.
I am on the more extreme with my opinion but I think there have to be consequences in this situation. Saying such comments is insanely messed up and in my eyes completely unacceptable, regardless of context or the person saying it (in our case, mod or not idc), regardless of whether the "intentions are good"; ESPECIALLY if those comments are directed towards someone from said minority group. Don't get me wrong, I wholeheartedly think anyone should have the right to believe in whatever they want to believe in, but I don't think religious background and upbringing should be used to "excuse" the comments made and things said. This type of lax behaviour is the backbone to the hatred towards different minority groups that we see both irl and online, from people with a religious background, nowadays; stuff like this is constantly being let slide and no one is ever held accountable. I am quite disappointed overall.
๐
10
relicsong
^
devilmine
at least with the "come back to god" part
devilmine
I mean the entire conversation was initialized to be around that topic so idk if its a valid concern to hold
g.ben
This is exactly why I wanted to bring this up... I do agree with the fact that Rose shouldn't have brought this up the way she did, but disregarding those two things Ausk said in the video just because Rose didn't handle the situation properly just feels ignorant to me if anything. It doesn't change the fact that those things were said and as Devilmine mentioned here, the fact that it was basically not even addressed in the response document concerns me even further because it's really hard to interpret the "I wanna talk to the Clique that god created and not you" in any other way. I don't believe Ausk has hatred towards trans people but from the things he said about identity and whatnot, it very much comes off in a way where it just feels like he is strongly against the entire idea because of his beliefs and most of the video just kind of feels like hes trying to convince Rose to "come back to god" which is another very big concern of mine.
devilmine
I dont know if I get my message across properly cuz I woke up a little bit ago but really not giving any explanations in the word choices or actions done and largely deflecting it on the aftermath and actions done by the other party in the document feels just a bit deflective to me and really doesn't serve me as a viewer as something that would affirm that those views are not true
I definitely don't think its a good view to boil it down to purely being because they are mod, but rather due to being a community figure as a whole that adds an extra layer of scrutiny as being in the spotlight of the community should put your views under more scrutiny, especially when it comes to a topic like transphobia or other hateful opinions its important IMO to have them called out for anyone that is somewhat present in the community at a larger scale.
Even though this entire thing seems overblown to some degree with everything that Ausk put in the document too its generally important to view things critically too and think about some of the implications, and IMO some of the things mentioned like the misgendering and also some of the statements are still by their nature pretty harmful and should be talked about more in the document and giving people a better idea why this was done and from what place you were coming from - maybe it's just me but there is just... Nothing that tells me "okay why did he use those pronouns" which would, at least to me, signal that it was an intentional choice. It generally seems to not necessarily talk about the actual mistakes of the content said besides 1-2 sentences which I just find pretty alarming because surely there would just be an actual "explanation" as to why those words were chosen like that
1kreno
i honestly agree with ben on some of the stuff being said in the video coming off wrong, and in a discussion like this saying "reasonable people will see it and leave it" being used to discourage people voicing their concerns isnt helping with the situation in my opinion
g.ben
I also have some reservations still about this entire case... I don't know either parties personally so I might just be missing something and I'm in no place to judge anyone, I was told about this drama a little over 2 months ago by a 3rd party, when I wasn't even on the team, regarding another drama which included Kiannuh framing multiple people behind their backs for their own gain (im not even sure if this was ever brought up here but thats a discussion for another day). I did see that it was mentioned that clique has a history of telling half true stories or taking things out of context but since I see everyone has kinda agreed on this entire situation being 100% a non issue after the apology, I want to give a new perspective on this in here too because eventho I myself am not effected by it, multiple things Ausk mentioned in the video, even after re-listening to it multiple times, the way he did it left me with a very sour taste in my mouth, "bad wording" or not...
swtcyn
Knowing Clique I highly disagree


